University information

Doctoral Research: Planning Productive Supervision Meetings

In this guide +

Useful doctoral supervision meetings connect work already attempted with a decision about what comes next. A short agenda helps you explain progress, expose uncertainty and leave with manageable actions. This guide offers an original preparation exercise; meeting arrangements and formal research requirements depend on the relevant institution and supervisory team.

Choose the decision you need

Begin with one question that needs discussion. “Talk about my chapter” is broad; “Does this chapter need a narrower comparison before I expand the analysis?” identifies a decision. Distinguish a request for academic advice from an administrative request that requires another authorised office.

If the underlying question remains unclear, practise with Turn a Broad Interest into a Researchable Question. Bring your own proposed answer or alternatives so the meeting has something concrete to examine.

Prepare evidence the reader can locate

Agree how and when to share material. Use a dated draft with page or section references, a brief account of changes and a few focused questions. Identify work in progress honestly. For a question about research design, the methods alignment workshop offers a separate fictional practice task.

Original meeting preparation card
BringMake clear
Draft sectionVersion and precise location
Unresolved questionDecision or advice requested
Attempted solutionReasoning and remaining uncertainty
Proposed next stepDependency and realistic scope

Try a focused agenda exercise

Imagine that a fictional researcher has read six relevant papers but cannot explain why two reach different conclusions. Their first agenda says “Literature review problems”. Rewrite it as: “I compared the samples and definitions in papers A and B; which difference should I investigate before revising section two?”

Prepare a short comparison, mark what remains uncertain and propose one follow-up task. This turns a general difficulty into a discussion the supervisor can assess. The six-paper example is invented and sets no reading requirement.

Record decisions and unresolved points

Before finishing, check your understanding of agreed actions, responsibility and any proposed dates. Distinguish a suggestion from a required revision. Afterwards, prepare a concise record through the agreed channel, with unresolved questions clearly labelled. Use the institution’s required recording process where applicable.

Keep the earlier draft so changes remain traceable. Detailed responses to formal reviewers are a separate task, illustrated in Respond to Peer Review with a Revision Matrix.

The Open University’s Preparing guidance supports understanding a learning task before planning work. It provides general study context, rather than an INTIAU supervision policy.

For broader context, see the Doctoral Degree page. Direct questions about current INTIAU arrangements through the University contact page.

Questions and answers

Should every meeting cover the whole project?

No. Agree priorities and include wider issues when they affect the immediate decision. Follow any formal review requirements separately.

What if I have made little progress?

Explain the obstacle, what you attempted and the help you need. An unfinished result can still support a focused discussion.

What if I disagree with advice?

Explain your reasoning and ask what evidence would resolve the difference. Record unresolved points and use the applicable institutional process if needed.

Does this guide establish a supervision schedule?

No. Confirm meeting frequency, draft-sharing expectations and recording requirements with the relevant supervisory team and current institutional guidance.

View the illustrative image
Learners reviewing study tasks with a tutor at a computer
Illustrative classroom scene: learners and a tutor discussing study tasks.

Privacy choices

Allow Google Ads measurement cookies and use of ad-click information to attribute visits to our public information pages? This optional measurement stays off until you accept. Separate analytics, personalised advertising and enhanced conversions remain off; we do not configure form-field collection. This new attribution permission is not covered by your earlier choice. You can refuse or change it at any time.

Read our privacy policy